We are finally beginning to get some good information regarding how banks and credit unions are doing coming out of their initial FACT Act Red Flag audits. The great news is that our clients are being given a passing grade by the auditors for using our Safe2Change solution to meet the address change provisions of FACT Act. Great news, because they deloyed Safe2Change as a much more cost-effective solution to complying versus sending out letter confirmations. At a time when costs are more critical than ever, saving some dollars here is very important, and our customers are able to realize these savings.
More interestingly, we are seeing a couple of general trends emerging from these audits that are worth thinking about.
Looks like the auditors are being somewhat lenient in this first pass. Clearly there are the handful that completely ignored the regulation and are getting it with both barrels. However - in the first round we are hearing that they are generally not having many issues.
The one gap that we are hearing now repeatedly is that the examiners are beginning to scrutinize compliance strategies where financial institutions are mailing letters to the customer's old and new address to achieve compliance. The issue is sufacing not because of the letter mailing strategy, but because FACTA requires that the institution not fulfill subsequent requests credit cards, debit cards, checks, etc. until the consumer has had enough time to receive and respond to the letter. This makes sense. If the institution sends out a letter and then sends the requested card to the new address (where the fraudster is waiting) - then this strategy will still still result in identity theft.
We are finding that most institutions have deployed the letter mailing strategy. However - we are also finding that these same institutions are not putting a "hold" on the account to block the request for cards and checks. This is not allowed per the FACT Act, which states that you can send letters, but not fulfill these additional requests until enough time has passed.
In these early examinations, we are hearing this issue being brought up repeatedly. While the examiners are being a bit lenient in round 1, we see this as being an issue that will be scrutinized much more and that financial institutions will need to plug this hole.
A.E>>>
In this blog, Adam Elliott, President of ID Insight, discusses various business issues in the fraud detection marketplace as well as provides some personal diatribes on business today.
Showing posts with label FACT Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FACT Act. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 2, 2009
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Too Busy To Save Money
This economic crisis becomes more of a circus each and every day. It wasn't too many days ago that Wells Fargo, Chase, and US Bank were being lauded for avoiding the crash that had hit others such as Countrywide, WAMU, etc...
Flash forward a few short months, and they are now in similar spots, cutting dividends and reporting record losses. It tends to make you wonder what other rocks that have yet to be turned over. It is getting downright scary.
Given that ID insight sells primarily to financial services companies, I am routinely asked how this recession is impacting us. Until very shortly - my response was pretty similar. What we offer is a way for banks to save money - so we hadn't seen much of a negtive impact.
However - as of late we have seen that begin to change. Normally - when you walk in the door and tell someone that they can save them significant amounts of money - they are interested - as they should be. Increasingly - however, we are hearing more banks explain that even though they are interested that they cannot afford the time to save money. We are finding many (more every day) banks that simply are looking to keep the doors open.
When we stop making sound, rational business decisions - that's when you realize that this is some really scary stuff.
A.E>>>
Flash forward a few short months, and they are now in similar spots, cutting dividends and reporting record losses. It tends to make you wonder what other rocks that have yet to be turned over. It is getting downright scary.
Given that ID insight sells primarily to financial services companies, I am routinely asked how this recession is impacting us. Until very shortly - my response was pretty similar. What we offer is a way for banks to save money - so we hadn't seen much of a negtive impact.
However - as of late we have seen that begin to change. Normally - when you walk in the door and tell someone that they can save them significant amounts of money - they are interested - as they should be. Increasingly - however, we are hearing more banks explain that even though they are interested that they cannot afford the time to save money. We are finding many (more every day) banks that simply are looking to keep the doors open.
When we stop making sound, rational business decisions - that's when you realize that this is some really scary stuff.
A.E>>>
Monday, December 1, 2008
What is the Real FACT Act Opportunity?
Dear Readers,
Well - here we are - now one month after the FACT Act compliance deadline. For those of you that expected fireworks and smoking computers - I am sorry to disappoint. While we definitely saw many banks scrambling at the last minute to get their plans in place - November 1st was, in many ways, a non-event. I guess in hindsight, this should not be overly surprising. We saw similar activity back when the USA Patriot Act went live. It was months and years before many banks got fully into compliance.
However - we have learned a few things since November 1st that are coming to fruition that I thought I would share.
First of all, most banking institutions took the easy route and deployed existing solutions in the new account environment to screen address discrepancies.
In doing so - these banking insitutions are now seeing their fraud queues nearly quadrupling. This is already ending up in double digits reductions in account approval rates. While many banks are now seeing this, most are looking at it as the cost of compliance and doing business.
On the address change front, most banks opted for sending letters to the old and new address to become compliant. These institutions are now realizing the overall cost and impact - and are now expressing a desire to tighten up these processes in early 2009.
We have been sharing this reality for the past 12 months about this impending 'pain' and that pain is now being realized. In a time when banks are closing the doors, cutting expensese at every turn and looking for ways to increase revenues - you sure would think they would be interested in ways to minimize the pain and grow the top line.
It will be interesting to see what happens when the first few banks go through their first post FACTA audit in the coming weeks and months.
More to come,
A.E>>>
Well - here we are - now one month after the FACT Act compliance deadline. For those of you that expected fireworks and smoking computers - I am sorry to disappoint. While we definitely saw many banks scrambling at the last minute to get their plans in place - November 1st was, in many ways, a non-event. I guess in hindsight, this should not be overly surprising. We saw similar activity back when the USA Patriot Act went live. It was months and years before many banks got fully into compliance.
However - we have learned a few things since November 1st that are coming to fruition that I thought I would share.
First of all, most banking institutions took the easy route and deployed existing solutions in the new account environment to screen address discrepancies.
In doing so - these banking insitutions are now seeing their fraud queues nearly quadrupling. This is already ending up in double digits reductions in account approval rates. While many banks are now seeing this, most are looking at it as the cost of compliance and doing business.
On the address change front, most banks opted for sending letters to the old and new address to become compliant. These institutions are now realizing the overall cost and impact - and are now expressing a desire to tighten up these processes in early 2009.
We have been sharing this reality for the past 12 months about this impending 'pain' and that pain is now being realized. In a time when banks are closing the doors, cutting expensese at every turn and looking for ways to increase revenues - you sure would think they would be interested in ways to minimize the pain and grow the top line.
It will be interesting to see what happens when the first few banks go through their first post FACTA audit in the coming weeks and months.
More to come,
A.E>>>
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Verified?
Today, we just got done analyzing the confirmed fraud addresses from the United States Postal Inspection Service, which is the law enforcement agency of the Post Office. We went back and looked at all the confirmed fraud addresses over the past 12 months. In doing so, we categorized all of the records into the category of fraud.
What we found was that 48% of the confirmed frauds were due to re-shipping schemes and that 41% of the confirmed frauds were due to a fraudulent change of address. Together - they represent 89% of all confirmed frauds.
What is interesting is that for both of these cases, any ID Verification service would have very likely indicated that the Name Matched the Address! For fraudulent address changes - the fraud artist changed the address from the victim's address to an alternate address. This would then be picked up by the third party verification providers as a confirmed address change. In the second situation - unsuspecting "mules" would receive merchandise that was being shipped to the actual person listed at the address.
Point is - in both cases, any traditional ID Verification service would confirm that the name and address matched! Over the past few years - a culture has developed that when we "match" the name to address that it must be "good". This matching would be considered sufficient or "reasonable" to any examiner as meeting USA Patriot Act, Bank Secrecy Act or Fact Act guidelines. As we can see above - it isn't that simple. Makes you wonder?
What we found was that 48% of the confirmed frauds were due to re-shipping schemes and that 41% of the confirmed frauds were due to a fraudulent change of address. Together - they represent 89% of all confirmed frauds.
What is interesting is that for both of these cases, any ID Verification service would have very likely indicated that the Name Matched the Address! For fraudulent address changes - the fraud artist changed the address from the victim's address to an alternate address. This would then be picked up by the third party verification providers as a confirmed address change. In the second situation - unsuspecting "mules" would receive merchandise that was being shipped to the actual person listed at the address.
Point is - in both cases, any traditional ID Verification service would confirm that the name and address matched! Over the past few years - a culture has developed that when we "match" the name to address that it must be "good". This matching would be considered sufficient or "reasonable" to any examiner as meeting USA Patriot Act, Bank Secrecy Act or Fact Act guidelines. As we can see above - it isn't that simple. Makes you wonder?
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
Some Additional Insight into the OTS Exam Procedures
I’m sure you are all aware of the big announcement from the OTS this month regarding the exam procedures for FACT Act Red Flag and Address Discrepancy. Nothing really earth-shattering came out in the announcement itself, the exam procedures outlined by the OTS follow the regs right down the line, just as they’ve been describing all along. What is interesting about the announcement is that it is a not-so-subtle reminder that the November 1st deadline and all the newly required policy, board review, and audit trail are very real.
When thinking about this, an old movie quote comes to mind: “It’s not what you know, it’s what you can prove.” When talking to banks about some of the compliance strategies they are planning to implement, I wonder how it will shake out when the auditors come around.
For example, for Section 315, which requires a belief of true identity to be formed when a credit report has a conflicting address with a consumer application. How do you provide an audit trail with a manual verification process? It can be done I’m sure -- but how easily? With an automated solution, the audit trail part couldn’t be simpler. System logs reveal every explicit detail of every factor associated with a question of identity and address change, and how it was handled with an empirically driven, risk-based approach with a push of a button. Okay, maybe two or three buttons -- but you get the point!
Stay tuned as we move down the stretch…
A.E>>>
When thinking about this, an old movie quote comes to mind: “It’s not what you know, it’s what you can prove.” When talking to banks about some of the compliance strategies they are planning to implement, I wonder how it will shake out when the auditors come around.
For example, for Section 315, which requires a belief of true identity to be formed when a credit report has a conflicting address with a consumer application. How do you provide an audit trail with a manual verification process? It can be done I’m sure -- but how easily? With an automated solution, the audit trail part couldn’t be simpler. System logs reveal every explicit detail of every factor associated with a question of identity and address change, and how it was handled with an empirically driven, risk-based approach with a push of a button. Okay, maybe two or three buttons -- but you get the point!
Stay tuned as we move down the stretch…
A.E>>>
Monday, January 28, 2008
Is Emergency Card Replacement Dead?
So here’s a question: Is emergency card replacement or rush shipping dead as we know it? As my ID Insight team continues to pour over the FACT Act Red Flag and Address Discrepancy rules, it’s becoming more apparent that the old way of doing business just won’t cut it anymore.
The FACT Act says that if a customer changes his or her address then calls back within 30 days to request a replacement card, the credit issuer is required to “assess the validity of that address change” before sending out the card. Many small banks and credit unions routinely send letters to verify an address. If we’re reading it correctly, after the November 1 FACT Act compliance date arrives, banks that continue using the mail as an identity-verification system simply won’t be able to send the card until the customer receives -- and is given a reasonable period of time to respond to -- the letter.
We’re digging more deeply into this potentially critical piece of FACT Act language with our industry advisors and attorneys. Are the days of getting a replacement card in less than 24 hours gone?
What do you think? I hope you’ll share your perspective on this, either by posting a comment on this blog or dropping me an email at adam.elliott@idinsight.com.
The FACT Act says that if a customer changes his or her address then calls back within 30 days to request a replacement card, the credit issuer is required to “assess the validity of that address change” before sending out the card. Many small banks and credit unions routinely send letters to verify an address. If we’re reading it correctly, after the November 1 FACT Act compliance date arrives, banks that continue using the mail as an identity-verification system simply won’t be able to send the card until the customer receives -- and is given a reasonable period of time to respond to -- the letter.
We’re digging more deeply into this potentially critical piece of FACT Act language with our industry advisors and attorneys. Are the days of getting a replacement card in less than 24 hours gone?
What do you think? I hope you’ll share your perspective on this, either by posting a comment on this blog or dropping me an email at adam.elliott@idinsight.com.
Monday, January 14, 2008
Compliance and FACT Act named top two challenges for 2008
Everywhere you look today, financial services news outlets are reporting about how compliance is the number one issue facing the industry this year. Last week, BankInfoSecurity.com followed suit and said the top two challenges in 2008 were “keeping up with compliance” and “FACT Act Red Flag Guidelines.” This should come as no surprise. Over the past few years, we have been accustomed to new compliance issues taking top billing on priority lists, such as the USA Patriot Act or Sarbanes-Oxley.
While everyone has their own take on compliance and the value, ID Insight is predicting that the new FACT Act Identity Theft Provisions will have the biggest positive effect on financial services compared to compliance issues of years past. The reason is that today, the major reason for the sustained increase in ID theft can be tracked back to the lack of controls around address changes and address discrepancies. The major theme of the FACT Act is to make sure that these controls are put in place. In doing so, we believe that the overall impact to the industry will be positive rather than a hindrance.
While everyone has their own take on compliance and the value, ID Insight is predicting that the new FACT Act Identity Theft Provisions will have the biggest positive effect on financial services compared to compliance issues of years past. The reason is that today, the major reason for the sustained increase in ID theft can be tracked back to the lack of controls around address changes and address discrepancies. The major theme of the FACT Act is to make sure that these controls are put in place. In doing so, we believe that the overall impact to the industry will be positive rather than a hindrance.
Thursday, January 3, 2008
Welcome to the ID Insight FACT Act Blog
Welcome to our “Facts on the FACT Act” Blog. I’m Adam Elliott, president and co-founder of ID Insight, Inc. And if you made a point of stopping by, you’re very likely just as interested as I am in exactly what the FACT Act is going to mean to your business.
For the foreseeable future, I’ll be offering my take on the latest FACT Act news, as well as commentary and tips, all designed to help banks, credit card issuers, retailers, wireless providers, online merchants, and financial services companies comply with the Red Flag rules as efficiently as possible. Some other ID Insight team members will likely contribute to the discussion along the way.
Let’s kick things off by talking about the reason behind all the discussion that’s happening in board rooms across the country: the FACT Act Red Flag rules.
The Red Flag rules have been a major question mark since the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions (FACT) Act was signed into law back in 2003. Last month, all that talk became a reality: The FDIC, Federal Reserve and several other federal regulatory agencies finalized the rules. By November 1, 2008, financial institutions and other creditors will be required to adopt a risk-based program to detect and prevent identity theft.
Under FACT Act Sections 114 and 315, financial institutions and creditors are now required by law to adopt procedures to reduce the risk of identity theft by examining consumer address changes on both new and existing accounts. Roughly 20 percent of new consumer credit applications feature a different address from the corresponding credit bureau file, so financial institutions using traditional address-verification methods are in for a lot of extra work and expense.
It doesn’t have to be all doom and gloom, though. In fact, if institutions take the right steps to comply with FACT Act, there are opportunities for millions of dollars in savings each year, especially for large banks that process thousands of applications every day.
In upcoming posts, I’ll talk about some easy-to-implement solutions to this often-confusing challenge. In the meantime, visit http://www.idinsight.com/ for more information and our free white papers on the Red Flag rules.
For the foreseeable future, I’ll be offering my take on the latest FACT Act news, as well as commentary and tips, all designed to help banks, credit card issuers, retailers, wireless providers, online merchants, and financial services companies comply with the Red Flag rules as efficiently as possible. Some other ID Insight team members will likely contribute to the discussion along the way.
Let’s kick things off by talking about the reason behind all the discussion that’s happening in board rooms across the country: the FACT Act Red Flag rules.
The Red Flag rules have been a major question mark since the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions (FACT) Act was signed into law back in 2003. Last month, all that talk became a reality: The FDIC, Federal Reserve and several other federal regulatory agencies finalized the rules. By November 1, 2008, financial institutions and other creditors will be required to adopt a risk-based program to detect and prevent identity theft.
Under FACT Act Sections 114 and 315, financial institutions and creditors are now required by law to adopt procedures to reduce the risk of identity theft by examining consumer address changes on both new and existing accounts. Roughly 20 percent of new consumer credit applications feature a different address from the corresponding credit bureau file, so financial institutions using traditional address-verification methods are in for a lot of extra work and expense.
It doesn’t have to be all doom and gloom, though. In fact, if institutions take the right steps to comply with FACT Act, there are opportunities for millions of dollars in savings each year, especially for large banks that process thousands of applications every day.
In upcoming posts, I’ll talk about some easy-to-implement solutions to this often-confusing challenge. In the meantime, visit http://www.idinsight.com/ for more information and our free white papers on the Red Flag rules.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)